Try the political quiz

0 Reply

 @5534JYNfrom Wigan answered…4yrs4Y

Good citizenship should be part of the national curriculum by law. Where this proves inadequate, troublemakers, especially persistent ones, should be sent to secure re'education centres where they will be subject to a 'carrot and stick' type of system.

 @9LVFKKQGreenanswered…2wks2W

Education should begin at school and be a LOT more in depth to deter people going into criminal lifestyles.

 @9LRDYZGGreenanswered…2wks2W

Yes, but these orders should be reformed, to only include behaviour with victims. Penalties should be reformed also; focusing on rehabilitation over punishment/humiliation.

 @8P26KKHanswered…3yrs3Y

Yes, but not for things like begging or anything related to vagrancy. Homeless people should not be punished for being homeless.

 @9LCPJ9Sanswered…1mo1MO

Yes, but if the beggars are homeless people, leave them out of it. Everyone else in there can get what they get. We have seen a devolution of public behaviour over the last few years and rising crime rates. The public are sick of it.

 @9L9XJ9Ffrom Florida answered…1mo1MO

No, the current implementation of the concept is classist (begging) and racist (what is often let off with a warning for a white person is taken further for people of colour, epecially black teenage boys)

 @9K67WTQ answered…3mos3MO

No, ASBOS historically do not achieve its aims. We should focus more on other methods of social support and anti-social behaviour management.

 @9K2SX9Bfrom Florida answered…3mos3MO

Yes for some behaviours that could be considered crimes, but no for behaviours that could fall under free speech and/or freedom of expression.

 @9JYPPKDanswered…3mos3MO

Yes if it is a last resort, but work on better mental health services and getting to the route of the problem first

 @9JX37QFanswered…3mos3MO

Only if the “antisocial behaviour” in question can be proven to cause harm to the offender and/or those around them

 @9HVBV52answered…4mos4MO

Young offenders who have ASBOS should instead be forced to join the military, like a national service

 @9HTKK9Vanswered…4mos4MO

No, They don't make a good deterrent. People use an ASBO as a badge of honour. Its had the opposite effect.

 @9HD7XT3 answered…5mos5MO

No, waste of time. Bring back corporal punishment. Public beatings and humiliation of low level criminals - would make great tv - I would watch ….

 @9H5YF5Tanswered…6mos6MO

Yes, as long as punishments are light and fair. The content of the speech made should never factor into the crime.

 @9GZQLSCanswered…6mos6MO

Instead of punishing young offenders, offer the free therapy and support and education away from their poor home life.

  @Kovu answered…7mos7MO

Yes and no, depends on the circumstances and individual(s), and, or the crime(s) and offence(s) committed, but overall, no I do bot support the use of them, I agree with discipline, accountability, and safeguarding, but ASBOS given are typically racist and discriminatory, and detrimental, also very ableist, things like mental health, criminality etc should be reworked and reformed, and have more education and training surrounding such.

 @9FVKSV6answered…7mos7MO

Yes but I think we need youth centres back and to actually put time and money into listening to young people, supporting them and channeling their energy into doing good and feeling like they're worth something.

 @9FM4K3Panswered…8mos8MO

 @9FJ5GBXanswered…8mos8MO

We should focus on community care and support to avoid antisocial behaviours

 @9CP2FCQanswered…10mos10MO

Neutral stance, depends on circumstances and I feel mental and physical health, and family lives of many who get ASBO'S whilst in some minor cases it may help, it's not affective long term and not really helpful, we should be looking at reforming and bettering mental and general health services and resources, rehabilitation programmes etc, especially where youth and young offenders are concerned

 @9C65XTBanswered…12mos12MO

They don’t work. Provide something for younger people to actually do. This is caused by a poor education system

 @93Y79MFLabouranswered…2yrs2Y

No, and shift the current funding in this area into education and activities for young people to prevent them turning to this behaviour

 @93XD6XSanswered…2yrs2Y

No, commuinty service is a more productive and rehabilitative punishment.

 @93V3YSKanswered…2yrs2Y

Yes, but remove harmless behaviours like begging and loitering from being defined as antisocial.

 @93SH3D2answered…2yrs2Y

 @93RMBW3answered…2yrs2Y

Yes, but provide support to encourage people towards prosocial behaviours, instead of just penalties

 @936WY66answered…2yrs2Y

No, some of these are much less serious issues than others and they should not be in the same category

 @932HQN4answered…2yrs2Y

I neither support nor am against ASBO use. I’d prefer to find more rehabilitative methods of dealing with those lacking in social skills.

 @92XC3SWanswered…2yrs2Y

No, there is little evidence that they form an effective deterrent and in some case can prevent reformed young offenders finding work later in life.

 @92S6PSRLabouranswered…2yrs2Y

Yes, but increase spending on social programs to help reduce the need for ASBOs

 @92S5WTBanswered…2yrs2Y

No, labelling a young person can have a detrimental effect, and actually push them towards further offending than away

 @92QMZX8answered…2yrs2Y

No, more work should be put in place to deter anti-social behaviour, such as the creation of free public spaces where teenagers can spend time, like libraries and parks

Engagement

The historical activity of users engaging with this question.

Loading data...

Loading chart... 

Demographics

Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion

Loading data...