A tax return is a document which states how much income an individual or entity reported to the government. In the UK these documents are considered private and are not released to the public. After David Cameron was named in the 2016 Panama Papers scandal top MP’s including Chancellor George Osborne and Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn published details of their tax returns. The UK Electoral Commission does not require individuals running for public offices to release them. In Sweden, Norway and Finland citizen’s and candidate’s tax records are considered public information and are published on the internet.
Narrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Political party:
Political theme:
Ideology:
Ideology:
Borough:
@5GLRHHG4yrs4Y
Everyone's tax returns should be public - the Norway model
I think they should be checked by an authority but only made public if there is a reason such as business interests, expenses etc
@B294NX41wk1W
No, but they should be subject to private audit by an independent body, and if deemed necessary, they can release them to the public
@B28Z62B1wk1W
No, but there should be private audits carried out by a non government funded private body which can call for a public audit if deemed necessary
@9ZNV5QHLibertarian 1mo1MO
They should be reported to a non-government, independent body that checks through them to increase transparency
@9SBTMJP5mos5MO
No, and only require them to release their tax returns to all the other MPs, Lords in the Houses of Parliament and the media for scrutiny
@9Q72V5Y6mos6MO
No but they should be transparent as to who pays them outside of their job and their main job should be the highest proportion of their taxable pay
@9PWDD5L 7mos7MO
No but they should be audited by independent organisations and disclosed if the tax paid is below a certain threshold
@9DYQZ6F1yr1Y
Only for high office positions
@9DM5PR51yr1Y
@9DJBRYP1yr1Y
Public officials need to back out of private enterprise all together
@9V44C4N4mos4MO
I believe in the legalisation of moving money, so long as customs are specific and the country is open to the destination of the monetary movement.
@9T6KPQT4mos4MO
Yes, if someone seeks public office and faces inherent conflicts of interest, they should absolutely be required to release their tax returns. It's no secret that politicians are often influenced by business interests, as they are frequently wined and dined by corporations seeking to push specific policies. By releasing their tax returns, the public can scrutinize their **financial ties** and ensure there are no hidden agendas or undue influence. This level of transparency would go a long way in reducing corruption and cronyism, as it would expose potential conflicts and discourage politicians from engaging in unethical financial behavior.
Yes, and require to release their medical records as well as a public audit each year they are in office
@9P6LYBDConservative7mos7MO
Yes, to prevent fraud and personal gain, as well as a yearly medical exam to ensure they are capable of being in office
@9P236WV7mos7MO
They should probably be required to have them scrutinised by their party, or (for independent candidates) someone else - maybe a central govt department.
@9FKMD471yr1Y
No, as this violates their human right to privacy
@9FJ2JQB1yr1Y
No they shouldn't be allowed to release their tax info but shouldnt be giving them selves benifits
@9FGDLSH1yr1Y
No but there should be someone to overview it
@9FFVFKQ1yr1Y
No, but any wrongdoing should be of public knowledge
There won't be political candidates in an Autocracy
@9PHWRXW7mos7MO
No, they should not be required to do so (where would this requirement stop?), but they should be encouraged. While it does not in principle affect their ability to perform public service, it will ensure that it is clear when they are conflicted or compromised.
@9PF84SW7mos7MO
No, but implement stricter laws on what expenses can be used for. Political lifestyles should not be so extravagant.
@9NFMDQV7mos7MO
There should be more effort to reduce corruption, MPs should not be allowed more than a certain % of income from sources other than their MP salary.
@9N2KLSP8mos8MO
Serving politicians should have their tax returns scrutinized by an independent panel instead of the public and there should be more stringent rules about conflicts of interest within their lives.
@9N2BXWZ8mos8MO
No, but there should be tighter and better systems to avoid tax evasion, loop holes and miss use of the tax system in 1st place
@9M5SRVF8mos8MO
I think it should be clarified that they haven’t got a history of black money and paid taxes properly like everyone else.
@9M3DCXS9mos9MO
Yes, and every year they are in office. Also, they should have at least 5 years of accounts audited to get onto the ballet.
@9LWCGYZ 9mos9MO
They should be encouraged to, and I would respect them more if they did, but they should be under no obligation to do so.
@9LH6RS69mos9MO
No their income has nothing to do with us but there should be harsher punishments on those that abuse the system
@9L898V310mos10MO
Yes, however in an abridged format to show what percentage of their financial position is classified as employment income vs investment/business net turnover, thereby allowing for public discourse regarding tax compliance vs tax avoidance and/or evasion. Any person holding an official public political position should be held to strict account if they potentially influence the course of law and fiscal decision making of the country.
@9L879JS10mos10MO
i mean taxation loophole exploitation needs to be for EVERYONE not just for the rich. again lower taxes increase freedoms higher taxes do not taxation doesn't fund anything
@9KSYJBGLiberal Democrat10mos10MO
Legislation where if asked or enquiry of tax returns they should be obliged to release the information
@9KLK3YZ10mos10MO
Yes, but only for selected and major reasons, not for private or potentially embarrassing purchases- there should be people checking their returns though but in private unless publicity was required.
@9K5F3MX11mos11MO
I think they should be held accountable if they’re doing the wrong thing but it is technically private
@9K3RRFSLiberal Democrat11mos11MO
Yes, it is vital for a country to thrive together and trust their leaders,this way they will be more understanding and respect authority more thus reducing crime rate and increase satisfaction on a National level
@9JKVLGX12mos12MO
Yes, and require a public audit each year they are in office, failure and strict legal actions, fines and removal from position never to be able to back.
@9JGFP5212mos12MO
it would make them more accountable but it shouldn't affect their ability to do their job, unless they are deliberately misleading the public and especially if they have any financial responsibilities in their role.
@9J2R4KC1yr1Y
Should be audited by a private independent parliamentary commission yearly for any wrong doings but otherwise the tax returns should remain private.
@9HPSF691yr1Y
No they shouldn’t be revealed to the public yet should be fair with the rest of the nation and approved of that.
@9HG6BQ41yr1Y
There should be a system in place that recognises whether a politician has been bought or paid to implement laws that only benefit the extremely wealthy.
@9H4LSXR1yr1Y
We should just know if they are paying taxes as they should but not the exact amount as there money is private.
@9GD53KH1yr1Y
They should only have to be obligated to show their tax returns and ins and outs if there is proof it is fraud. They and their close members, donators , beneficiaries, should be regularly monitored.
@9G5MCLJ1yr1Y
Yes, they should also release medical records, and require public audits alongside passing a competency test.
@9FRFHMS1yr1Y
No, unless they receive large sums off money and it’s not clearly explained they should be encouraged to voluntarily show tact return, but should be frowned upon to release or force a candidate to release without credible reason, and remind government officials or whistleblowers have the right to leak them but will likely face prosecution.
Case by case basis and use common sense
@9FQW8LL1yr1Y
Transparency is good. When individuals select to have a career in politics they should sign a declaration to allow they’re taxes to be made available eon request (random selection)
@9FPJX531yr1Y
No, they should just pay their taxes properly
@9FNGJMB1yr1Y
I think that they should be audited before being allowed to run but I don't think the public is required to know the specifics
@9F59PG61yr1Y
Only at a certain level (e.g. party leadership and cabinet)
@9NNH94J7mos7MO
Yes, if the tax returns are relevant to how they're spending government funds/claiming tax payers money
@9MGDY9Q8mos8MO
They should be reviewed by an unbiased party that ensures both psychologically and morally they are not unfit to lead
@9MB872Q8mos8MO
Yes, and I believe that if you are prime minister you should not earn money whilst you hold the position it should be an honour and privilege to lead the country. Potentially I would agree for them to earn national minimum wage.
@9B4DNTF2yrs2Y
All Taxes should be abolished
@9CCMY9R2yrs2Y
Yes, but only on request if an issue has arisen
@9BZ7T26Liberal Democrat2yrs2Y
if their integrity is in question then it should be mandated.
@9BVPFKT2yrs2Y
That’s personal information and if they make it known, their information is exposed
@9BNHJTZ2yrs2Y
No - but there should be public audit.
@9BMFYFH2yrs2Y
It's important to see how trustworthy they are
@9B84XHJ2yrs2Y
The Monarch should be head of state!
@99YR26F2yrs2Y
No, It shouldn't be shared but their families tax returns should be monitored to prevent scoundles.
@99Y6HT62yrs2Y
No, but there should be an independent non bias review of candidates which includes tax returns.
@92YXDMQ3yrs3Y
no but their taxes should be monitored by the appropriate people to ensure they are paying them accordingly
@92XDM233yrs3Y
Tax records should be public knowladge
@92XC3SW3yrs3Y
Yes, and they should be subject to an annual audit, prevented from voting on bills in which they have a vested interest. Their records should be made public as a part of the ballot registration process.
No but they should be required a public audit each year they are in office, with the spending records readily available to the public.
@8S9LQQF4yrs4Y
Yes, with a public audit every two years. More often uses more resources than necessary
@8S4R5QP4yrs4Y
Sending recent tax returns to the Office for Budget Responsibility should be mandatory and releasing them to the public should be voluntary (although I would respect them more if they did)
@8RR5CYL4yrs4Y
It should be monitored by a trusted agency.
@8RHF3JK4yrs4Y
No but if they are dodging taxes then they should expect to be punished in the same way we would be.
Yes, everyone’s tax return should be made public and there should be nowhere to hide.
@8QDWYT34yrs4Y
Yes, and they should have to release their medical records, and be required to undertake an audit each year they are in office.
@8Q6F3TY4yrs4Y
only is there is reasonable suspicion for them to do so
Yes we want our MPs to have integrity and not con the system they are meant to uphold
@8PYT5RH4yrs4Y
It shouldn’t be required, but I view the candidate who do, do it, as much more trust worthy.
@8PY48CF4yrs4Y
If they are going to be involved in tax-related politics then yes.
@8PRB2BM4yrs4Y
No, but they should be encouraged to do so voluntarily.
@8LBTZVM4yrs4Y
It should be encouraged.
@8KN443F4yrs4Y
Yes (to ensure they haven’t done anything fraudulent) but not medical records
@8KGGQM84yrs4Y
No, but if their policies on taxes contrast to their tax activity, then yes. So essentially if they have any drastic policy changes.
@8GFNG8P4yrs4Y
Only if they are questioned about it then it should be released
@rcm2020Liberal Democrat4yrs4Y
Their tax payments should be checked by higher authority especially if suspected of wrong doing but not released to the public due to safety issues.
@8C5524L4yrs4Y
Yes and require public auditing of themselves and family for the rest of their lives.
@9CXGFPR1yr1Y
No, unless they are the leader of a major political party and therefore a candidate for Prime Minister
@9CP22GY2yrs2Y
No, unless they’re labour
@9CL7FQ92yrs2Y
No, unless over £100k income
@9CKDCP72yrs2Y
No, but they still pay taxes and there should be more government transparency
@9CK37CB2yrs2Y
no but they should be paying taxes
@9CHKJ2S2yrs2Y
I don’t think it should be released to the public but an independent body to review them
@9CGGX7R2yrs2Y
Democracy as a whole is a flawed system and at times a one party state or ruler is better.
@9CCX3QZ2yrs2Y
@9CBM4JDLiberal Democrat2yrs2Y
It depends on what level of political candidate you mean - MPs and above - yes. Council candidates - no.
@9C9CNCG2yrs2Y
All political members should all be on the same salary and should have to declare their benefits they get from the job.
@9C5XPXK2yrs2Y
No but monitor them to ensure theyre not doing dodgy business
@9C3C7L62yrs2Y
Yes, but only if there is a valid reason.
@9BTX993Conservative2yrs2Y
No, unless they are subject to an investigation into any wrongdoing
@9BSZNPP2yrs2Y
No but they should submit them to a regulation board for politician which is unbiased.
@9BS2B4J2yrs2Y
Yes, and any members of parliment shouldn't be allowed to work a second job.
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.