In. November 2017 French President Emmauel Marcon proposed creating a central European intelligence agency. The proposal would pool each member country’s intelligence services into a single agency which would help combat terrorism.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Discussions from these authors are shown:
Political party:
Political party:
@9HQSR2G1yr1Y
No, information regarding the UK should be kept to UK intelligence agencies only to protect national security.
@9MZS2JC10mos10MO
No, each country needs their own intelligence agencies to be nationally secure. However, there should be better communications between agencies to allow discussions/tracking of threats to the wider area.
@9M5TKPJ11mos11MO
We should be increasing our own Intelligence Agencies first, but collaborate with some other countries that are trusted allies.Not all EU Countries can be trustworthy.
@9LVDVJH11mos11MO
Shared intelligence could put the uk in a Vulnerable position Regarding national security however Intelligence should be merge to protect our national security also
@9JFRQ981yr1Y
They should not be merged, but they should work together, and a central EU agency should instead be formed.
@982CX352yrs2Y
Member nations should have the right to retain an independent intelligence agency, but combat terrorism and organised crime via a central EU agency.
@96N4FLG2yrs2Y
should still keep their own but also have a shared one
No, but increase sharing of information, particularly for international criminals
@9432ZLP3yrs3Y
should all intelligence agencies globally be mocked and exposed?
@93FBJFN3yrs3Y
No, but increase cooperation between already existing agencies
@jdp20223yrs3Y
That is a matter for the countries within the EU, not the uk
@92KBR363yrs3Y
No, but they should have an almost coalition, to make sure they can both work independently and together.
@8ZNGB2Q3yrs3Y
No, But we should make an agreement to share intelligence.
@8Z5KP5Z3yrs3Y
@8YMV9DS3yrs3Y
Yes, there is relative stability in Europe and it benefits every member of the EU to pool together out resources to ensure this stability remains.
@8YL9BMN3yrs3Y
There should be more collaboration between intelligence agencies would be my first instinct, but, having not worked in any intelligence agencies, I don't have enough knowledge to pass judgement on this question.
@8Y75G4S3yrs3Y
no but there should be greater and easier sharing of intelligence
@8XNJ4PL3yrs3Y
we are not going to join as we have left the eu
@8WMWMSR3yrs3Y
Only if all members of the EU were trustworthy to use that power for the good of the people, which I think the UK isn't.
@8SQV6Z84yrs4Y
@8S9H3RSConservative4yrs4Y
No, A separate central agency should be formed.
@8S5W7XJ4yrs4Y
No but have good communication between intelligence agencies of different countries
@8RW4TKW4yrs4Y
There should be greater sharing of intelligence with an over-arching international committee to ensure equity
@8QXMLLT4yrs4Y
No but should work together to progress security
@8QS5GWP4yrs4Y
I believe agency’s souls help one another
@8QLRPLC4yrs4Y
Yes, but a central EU agency should exist alongside each countries individual agencies.
@8Q7CH8P4yrs4Y
No, and we should not have such intelligent agencies as we currently have.
@8PSV56R4yrs4Y
No, we shouldn’t have secret police and other underground intelligence agencies
@8D9MDTC5yrs5Y
No, because that would subvert national authority in favor of the EU which is supposed to be a trade organisation, not a political body
@9BH853C2yrs2Y
No, there would be benefits, but the information risk is too great.
@98VQQ7MLiberal Democrat2yrs2Y
maybe. but keep internal ones as well?
@92DPS4W3yrs3Y
Not merged but regulated by central EU agency
@95FVRXM3yrs3Y
No, but increase information sharing across agencies.
No, but they should still work closely together
@953RQKB3yrs3Y
But if the agencies are investigating each other, how does that work under the radar..?
@8RPB6TK4yrs4Y
No, there should be a central EU agency as well as each country having their own intelligence agency.
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.
