Should critical race theory be taught in primary and secondary school?
Critical race theory is the claim that institutions, laws, and history are inherently racist. It argues that white people have put up social, economic, and legal barriers between the races in order to maintain their elite status, both economically and politically and that the source of poverty and criminal behavior in minority communities is due exclusively to these barriers.
Narrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Discussions from these authors are shown:
Political party:
Political party:
@9VTRVL36mos6MO
I don't think it makes much difference to teach it to people because it shouldn't still be in affect but I'm not an expert so if the government is institutionally racist than it can't hurt to make children aware
@9QR28SH9mos9MO
No, this is a valuable topic but it is taught at a post-graduate level topic, none of its advocates are seriously suggesting it because brought into schools.
@9QKDMMC9mos9MO
Yes it should be taught, but it should not be taught as fact; it is a “theory” after all and we should be taught to either support or critique it through a balanced lens, casting a “critical” eye!
@9Q2HR8Z9mos9MO
No, history should be there only to learn from and move forward from, not constantly be used as an excuse as to why people are where they are in the here and now.
@9PXHFMX9mos9MO
Critical race theory is an academic concept of legal frameworks well beyond what would be taught in school, this question is irrelevant. But it could be beneficial for children to understand some of its very basic concepts.
@9PVPCTP9mos9MO
Not till secondary school. Add Intersectionality and the 1619 Project into this curriculum too however these are just theories and children are not inherently racist and can achieve anything they want with the drive & vision.
@9PVJKGY9mos9MO
This is tough- when considering a new cirriculum i believe you have to be careful with what material is shown to influential kids. Everyone should be educated of thier history and hhistory or our laws, institutions ect but must be delivered as accurate information and perhaps not until later in school.
Critical Race Theory is a university level course, nobody is teaching it in Primary or Secondary Schools.
@9PN73FY9mos9MO
No, we should be taught about the wider human race, how to eliminate all types of racism whilst learning about how historical racism.and discrimination has.shaped where we are now so we can learn from previous generations mistakes
@9PMS5G49mos9MO
Yes but they should be given full and accurate context of our history, and the legacy of oppression, colonialism and racism which has impacted our society today
@9PM86HV9mos9MO
No, because critical race theory is an A-level or degree level topic. However issues of race and the history of racial discrimination should be taught.
@9PM4TDR9mos9MO
No, but because it is a graduate-level legal theory, not because teaching about systemic and institutional racism is wrong
@9PLNQ2P9mos9MO
There shouldn't be a specialised subject regarding CRT, it should be taught as history and not glossed over in regards to racial tensions, slavery, etc.
@9PFYT4S10mos10MO
No, but kids should be raised to acknowledge the racist elements of our history that are often ignored
@9PCML7W10mos10MO
No, as Critical Race Theory presently lacks the necessary nuance to be a useful lesson for children.
@9P9THFQ10mos10MO
This is a very US based question for a UK election - although bias based on race is important here priviledge and prejudice based on class has more effect
@9P6JWZB10mos10MO
We should teach a balanced view including many different theories and allow children to form their own opinions
This question feels quite American and not particularly in keeping with the conversation around race in the UK
@9NLPKCS10mos10MO
better overall awareness of racism should be taught, however, the issue with racism isn't to do with children but ignorant adults
@9NL6TJM10mos10MO
There is no easy answer, but I think the discussions should be held once the kids are in secondary school
@9LN3QH612mos12MO
Its a Graduate level theory. Its not, nor has it ever been taught in primary or secondary school. Teaching children about racism is not Critical Race Theory. This question is deliberately misleading.
@9L2BFZ31yr1Y
I’m secondary school but not in primary school. Primary school kids should be colour blind and teaching them about racism might make them racist especially if they don’t properly understand.
This is irrelevant because children are not and have never been taught this academic theory in the UK. It is a total fallacy designed to stir up culture wars.
@9FC4P9C2yrs2Y
This is irrelevant as it relates to uk school children. The British history of systematic racism is not the same as the Americans and thus needs to addressed differently. For example there needs to be more emphasis on British empire history of racism and imperialism. Additionally racism and discrimination in contemporary British society should also be discussed in a sensitive manner that also students to talk about it with any judgement or blame. It should be taught at a secondary school level.
@9QLZBBW9mos9MO
I believe it is extremely important to learn about racism and systematic racism, because the only way we’re going to get over being racist is to talk about it. However, if it was to be taught it needs to be taught in a very careful and specific way that doesn’t cause conflict between pupils and should only be taught once they are old enough to process and think rationally about it because I can see situations happening where this causes more racism in school or people of colour avoiding or resent white people, which is the opposite effect of what we would want.
@9QJQ5CQ9mos9MO
We should simply be treating everyone the same and rebuilding the system from the ground up with students understanding and having knowledge of the theory.
@9NC2DHM10mos10MO
Yes, in secondary school. Primary school kids should be educated on racism, and colonialism as part of history lessons
@96BHNFC2yrs2Y
Whilst valid, critical race theory is far from the whole story. Powerful groups of humans have exploited weak groups of humans throughout history, and race is just one of many socioeconomic subdivisions. I feel that concentrating on race disproportionally risks hiding larger issues of the burgeoning mass inequality in society generally.
@93J328FLibertarian3yrs3Y
Let parents choose which school they wish to send their kids to.
@92YTJ993yrs3Y
Yes, but teach all theories and that CRT is not accepted as fact. Nothing should really be banned.
This literally doesn't mean anything
@8ZQTDXV3yrs3Y
Critical Race Theory is not appropriate in Primary Schools but, if taught sensitively, can be a useful lens through which to review social, cultural, and historical evidences of racism, misogyny, and other prejudices.
@8ZKKW6J3yrs3Y
We should be taught about racism, it’s history, causes and impacts but this should be with a view of ending racism
@8YG7WN83yrs3Y
This is a kinda Americacentric question and also baiting, this is not an either/or question. A revisionist history should be taught to all, and all nuances therein (an account can never be fully objective nor exhaustive).
@8WTY7Y43yrs3Y
Implement history in history classes in secondary schools.
@8VSY84L4yrs4Y
No because it’s very subjective. But curriculum should include eg, slavery which impacts on modern society. In this way children should be encouraged to apply critical thinking for themselves
@8VD8XR54yrs4Y
This is not taught in primary and secondary schools.
@8TBMM374yrs4Y
Yes, but only as part of GCSE, A Level or equivocal History or Politics subjects.
@8SF34T54yrs4Y
I don’t think it’s beneficial to encourage thought about racism but I think it is good to acknowledge history to learn from it
@8S88LXR4yrs4Y
Yes but it should not be mandatory.
@8QDT9ST4yrs4Y
It’s important to understand the past and the impact it has had on people and it’s important we learn form the past in order to change the now and the future. People are people - white, black, yellow, orange - the only difference should be if they’re good/nice people or not nice.
@9CWSNKM2yrs2Y
it should be taught to year 10 & 11
@9CVN4F62yrs2Y
No, but historical facts which demonstrate racism and it's effects should certainly be taught.
@9CN8PD62yrs2Y
Children in primary and secondary school are generally not capable enough to understand critical race theory, which is why it is not taught until college.
@9CFG77F2yrs2Y
CRT is mostly a university-level topic. Many of the answers here reflect a US perspective. But primary and secondary children should be taught honestly about racism and its effects, and the state's complicity in it.
@8XXD2H8Women's Equality3yrs3Y
they should be taught the history and modern problems of racism and teach them not to be racist
I think we should teach British history and black history more broadly. Where this teaching intersects with aspects of CRT then that’s fine, but I wouldn’t teach it as a discrete topic without giving other alternate theories to the origin and proliferation of race and it’s complexities.
@9NL8HGW10mos10MO
It's a controversial issue, Cody! Some believe that teaching critical race theory in primary and secondary schools can help students understand historical and current issues related to race and racism. On the other hand, some argue that it may be too complex or divisive for younger students.
The political themes of 41k users that upvoted this question
Join in on more popular conversations.