Should the United Kingdom transition to a four-day workweek?
Countries including Ireland, Scotland, Japan, and Sweden are experimenting with a four-day workweek, which requires employers to provide overtime pay to employees working more than 32 hours per week.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Political theme:
Political party:
@ISIDEWITH3yrs3Y
Yes
@9GD2S6G1yr1Y
The UK economy is already underproductive internationally, a four-day work week would only make this worse.
@9GB4PQT1yr1Y
I think it creates a sense of power for the workforce that would then lead to an overturn in hierarchy as the workforce would want more and would eventually treat the new Thursday as the old Friday.
@ISIDEWITH3yrs3Y
No
@9GB4PQT1yr1Y
If you give a group of people something, they are likely to push further to see how much more they can get out of it. So to reduce to a 4 day workweek would just create the same lazyness and make the workforce push for a 3 day workweek.
@9P7MM3H6mos6MO
Yes, wherever feasible (understanding that it may not be possible for essential jobs like emergency services). Most jobs office jobs don't need to be done 5 days a week and reducing working hours could have big environmental benefits by reducing emissions.
@9PMS7K95mos5MO
It should be an option for employees if it can be proven their work can be done in 4 days and not negatively affect their income
@9LP4YWZ7mos7MO
Maybe, why not trial it. More time off may result in happier economy which may result in less suicide and/crime rate. Maybe
@9RKBWGFLiberal Democrat4mos4MO
If a company requires a 4 day work week, it should be required to pay overtime for anything over those 4 days.
@9PJNLSY5mos5MO
Yes in theory, but like many things mentioned throughout this survey, it'll probably have to wait some time before it could be possible.
@9PGG5N7Conservative5mos5MO
If is optional. I would love a 4-day working week if it meant longer days but no reduction in salary.
@9PFXXQ25mos5MO
Yes, providing we invest in the technology to reduce pressures on workload capacities and we ensure there is no-detriment to existing salaries.
@9NYLWQH6mos6MO
I think it's best to agree on what is legally required per week (before over time) then allow employees to choose between spreading that between 5 or 4 days.
@9NJQ7XHLibertarian6mos6MO
Yes I agree personally but it should not be made mandatory and allow individual citizens to decide for themselves
@9PSP9YD5mos5MO
It cant be a national program but more encouragement and allowance for it depending on circumstances. Employers should be flexible
@9PLJ32K5mos5MO
I think the four-day workweek could be effective if implemented correctly and ensuring higher standards of work, but at current levels of working rate I do not think it would be beneficial overall.
@9PL6N3H5mos5MO
This will only work if the world can align to a four-day week i.e. all have the same three days off. Otherwise it will end up being exploited. Also, there needs to be a view on how this impacts the service industry.
@9PK5T6D5mos5MO
The right to request a 4 day work week should be enshrined in law. Employers should be able to consider it and decide to offer it or not depending upon the role.
@9P7HMZG6mos6MO
Again it depends on people’s circumstances and if they can afford to potentially lose income as overtime is not guaranteed
@9P726MM6mos6MO
No, but there needs to be more emphasis on the ability to condense hours, or have opportunities to work from home.
@9P4GG7F6mos6MO
As above - in the current climate a shorter work week will put more stress on companies - but flexitime and flexible working would be a great next step to moving towards shorter work weeks.
@9P3BMXZ6mos6MO
they should be allowed to choose to have a four day week but the four day week shouldn’t be compulsory
Less work less pay reduces with no pay increase especially for nurses will mean lower living standards
@9NZZK8C6mos6MO
No, work has health and wellbeing benefits. However people should be encouraged to find the right kind of work for them.
@9NZJRTW6mos6MO
The government should incentivise and pilot schemes in both the public and private sectors to test the effectiveness of a 4-day work week.
@9ND4DY3Liberal Democrat6mos6MO
Yes but this doesnt mean 60hrs to be worked in 4 days, there needs to be strict employer regulations ensuring people are not expected to work 12hr days just to have a 4 day working week.
Deleted6mos6MO
No, but whatever your weekly hours are, they should be in your contract and you should get overtime when you go over that.
@9N657HQ6mos6MO
If the 40 hour salary is met, many people would not be able support their lives and families on a 32 hour week pay. Companies will expect more work to be done in those 32 hours and be reluctant to allow overtime.
@9M3NJ9M7mos7MO
No, businesses should be able to open whenever they like without government mandated times in order to encourage competition and innovation
@9LNJ7GMLiberal Democrat7mos7MO
It should be optional but if you opt for a 4 day working week you will not be eligible for overtime pay.
@9LMW7N47mos7MO
It's definitely worth experimenting with and trialling; I feel I need more information to have an informed view.
Only if it can definitely be shown to improve productivity and not damage the economy, whilst allowing flexibility for employers.
@9L8HZLVConservative8mos8MO
Yes, but only where it’s viable. Many service based businesses can do this, but businesses producing goods or agricultural products would find this difficult.
@9L7W9VL8mos8MO
No, because five-day workweek is low enough but require overtime pay for work over five days per week
@9KB5YXXLiberal Democrat9mos9MO
I think this should be done however the government should fund the losses that business will incur for missing out on earning potential for jobs that require a 24/7 approach such as haulage.
@9K7B7549mos9MO
For those sectors where this is viable absolutely as it has been demonstrated to increase productivity, morale, and work-life balance. Where this can be implemented it should. However, there are some sectors where this will not be possible.
@9K7B58Q9mos9MO
Yes, if it is not a particular industry that would face a significant impact from a day lost such as Facilities Management
@9JYMMMQ10mos10MO
Not legally transition, but encourage and allow the market to show the pros and cons in action, including employee retention and company performance.
@9JG967S10mos10MO
No, but employers should be encouraged to promote flexible working hours to allow people to work the times they are most productive
@9HN5H3D12mos12MO
Whilst it is a good idea it’s not practical enough to execute and is too complex to correctly implement
Yes, and abolish the 48 hour working time directive. People should be free to work as little and as long as they want.
@9HBJHB212mos12MO
Yes. Unless a job really needs more than 4 days coverage and the role/hours are known and agreed from outset
@9H4RYRT1yr1Y
No, this should be a free choice, with no punishments made to the employee(s) so long as the hours are worked
@8YPK9B4 1yr1Y
Yes, but with exceptions for some industries or occupations where this would be detrimental to employees/employers.
@9FLR736 1yr1Y
Yes, but as long as the output of work is similar or the same as when it was a 5 day work week.
@9FJTBGD1yr1Y
Yes, lower to a 32-hour work week where anymore time gives you more pay, to reduce burnout.
@9FJTBGD1yr1Y
No, instead reduce to a 32-hour work week where anymore time gives you more pay, to reduce burnout.
@9FJVLS21yr1Y
Yes, but four longer 10 hour days
@9FJDTR31yr1Y
No but only for Public sector
@9FDZHZN1yr1Y
Only if it is not forced, companies mist find the natural balance with workers and in turn, workers must integrate this into their lives.
@9FDG89W1yr1Y
Should be entirely for employers and employees to negotiate with no government interference
@9FBD77R1yr1Y
Depends on necessity of job.
@9F9HCG51yr1Y
Transition to a four day week for all once the cost of living issue has been fixed. Not everybody could afford a four day working week.
@9DSC38J1yr1Y
Should be company-led, not government-mandated.
@9DDD9581yr1Y
Let businesses make their own decisions, provided they give their workers bargaining power to decide as well
@9DCWFC21yr1Y
No not yet. We need to see it working elsewhere and in what jobs it cannot work.
@9D9DL471yr1Y
No, but offer more holidays that are easier to get
@9D8FLHX 1yr1Y
No but only if it’s scientifically proven to improve work efficiency and results
@9D579WW1yr1Y
No not possible but overtime should be paid and not expected
@9D4B88Y1yr1Y
More analysis and public consultation is needed. It should be at the discretion of each individual as to how many hours they choose to work voluntarily, in excess of any statutory minimum/maximum.
@9PBX9CN5mos5MO
As long as it doesn't mean we work less that our current contractual hours. Getting the same money for doing less is not right
@9P83GDM6mos6MO
It would be great but how are we going to pay for all the extra people required for public services (NHS, police etc)?
@9P8BHHY6mos6MO
No but require overtime pay for any days over the five per week and if you work more than 5 days in a row
@9NV25JC6mos6MO
Difficult to implement, will harm smaller businesses and those that require employees to cover a specific time periods to support others, such as childcare industry, where recruitment and retention is already hugely challenging.
@9N24HYC6mos6MO
Yes, but not through law as there are exceptions. It should keep the maximum 40 hours work week or pay overtime
If there is a national payrise then maybe it can work as 4 days. But as most people struggle to get by working 6 days then its circumstation to how much you get paid
@9M3RVZJ7mos7MO
Any set of working conditions I.e Salary,Work Pattern should be set and agreed by the Employer and the Employee prior to employment. This doesn't need regulation
@9M38WJ57mos7MO
Yes, where this is suitable and applicable for the role to be effective and the service to not be affected.
Again, I would love this, but as a small business owner the employment costs are too high to provide the amount of staff willing to work 32hrs a week and be able to support themselves, not to mention how hard it is to find staff post - Brexit.
@9PPDW2H5mos5MO
If salaries stay the same over the 4 days as they would be previously however overtime isn’t guaranteed and could impact lower income households
@9PNRK325mos5MO
Not in every career perhaps but it could boost the economy with more off time to spend within the country
@9NX85JM6mos6MO
Yes, but this change should be made gradually to allow businesses to adjust without hindering their operations
@9NX4H876mos6MO
If it is possible to complete full time hours in four days and there is no detrimental effect to the employer
@9D355DL1yr1Y
More research is needed to make a more informed decision
@967W4732yrs2Y
Only for those who opt to a four day week
@964GPY92yrs2Y
If the UK can be as productive in 4 days as 5 over a 5 year average then yes
Only for certain occupations
@94PXX6Z2yrs2Y
We should try it out first. Not just implement and hope for the best
@94KK25DLibertarian2yrs2Y
No a 3 day weekend is ideal
@94GVNKT2yrs2Y
Yes, it may be more productive as employees have more energy and feel happier with their job.
@94CKMVN2yrs2Y
Only if productivity can be maintained or increased. Robots will enable this soon enough when jobs finally disappear ( along with incomes)
@944KCYY2yrs2Y
This should be an option to all employees not a ‘mandate’.
@942MBPN2yrs2Y
Yes, France did it, and they were fine
@93Z9DZGPlaid Cymru2yrs2Y
@93W6KCJ2yrs2Y
Work weeks should be determined by businesses
@93W32T62yrs2Y
Depends on how the company wants to run it
Depends on the business really
@93QTGYX2yrs2Y
No but everyone should get a day off during the voting day of a general election
@93M6LDS2yrs2Y
Yes, with the ability for employees to choose the amount of days, provided productivity is not lost, at the same rate of pay as a five-day working week.
@93HXC322yrs2Y
In some sectors, based on testing.
@93BW6GT2yrs2Y
@9392HJY2yrs2Y
Yes but depends on the job
@933KDXW3yrs3Y
It should be up to the company
@8YMV9DS3yrs3Y
Yes, a four day work week would boost productivity by a large margin(Wednesday being the most effective day to use, but would remain flexable)
@8Y6T46Y3yrs3Y
Only if they can afford this, other people may not be able to not work and may have to work everyday
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.