Should critical race theory be taught in primary and secondary school?
Critical race theory is the claim that institutions, laws, and history are inherently racist. It argues that white people have put up social, economic, and legal barriers between the races in order to maintain their elite status, both economically and politically and that the source of poverty and criminal behavior in minority communities is due exclusively to these barriers.
Narrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Political party:
Political party:
@ISIDEWITH4yrs4Y
No
@9F6LYF72yrs2Y
If children have experienced racism then privileged children have the means and ability to learn about it and prevent situations where their classmates experience it, and in later life so socialisation takes place.
@9LJQZFJ 12mos12MO
And what dose that have to do with the colour of a person's skin?
@9M2MF9N11mos11MO
Pupils in today's climate think they are victims - either of racism, sexism, victims of poverty. Indeed they may be. But there is no use in dwelling in this. They need to get up and work and do their best. Racism shall not define them, they are free to make a life for themselves.
However too many school pupils are taught that this is impossible and we should sit patiently feeling sorry for outselves until racism has been 'solved' by government.
@ISIDEWITH4yrs4Y
No, kids should be raised to be racially color blind instead of being taught they are inherently racist or disadvantaged based on the color of their skin
@9FMN3XY2yrs2Y
It creates a victim mindset, of which ethnic minorities are better than this. Children should be raised to treat everyone fairly and view everyone equally, not that their white friends are more privileged than them.
@9HP3ZXV1yr1Y
An equal society can only be achieved if we are taught that we are all equal no matter the colour of our skin. We should judge people based on their beliefs, not because of their history and where their forefathers came from
@9M9VZZZLiberal Democrat 11mos11MO
In my perspective, the inclusion of Critical Race Theory (CRT) in K-12 education is divisive and counterproductive. Instead of fostering unity, it promotes a society focused on racial differences, hindering our pursuit of equality. I advocate for a racially colour-blind approach, where everyone is treated equally, regardless of their race.
Furthermore, I staunchly oppose the victim mentality narrative, particularly among people of colour. Empowerment, resilience, and personal agency are crucial for overcoming obstacles. While acknowledging historical injustices, I believe in personal responsib… Read more
@9ZX94T34mos4MO
Proponents of teaching CRT in schools argue that it provides important tools for understanding systemic racism and inequality, fostering a more inclusive and aware society. They contend that CRT can help students understand the historical and social structures that shape current people playground racial dynamics, encouraging empathy and critical thinking skills. Scholars and educators like Ibram X. Kendi and Gloria Ladson-Billings, who advocate for antiracist education, argue that this approach is necessary for addressing persistent racial disparities in education, the criminal justice system, and other aspects of society.
@9FVSV221yr1Y
I believe that kids, even teenagers, are still either too innocent or too impressionable to teach them about "the problems of a racist society". Instead of pointing out that everything is racist we should make children ignore it. If there's people from Africa, other parts of Europe etc and they are treated normally, there will be no racism.
@ISIDEWITH4yrs4Y
Yes, we cannot end racism until we acknowledge that our institutions, laws, and history are inherently racist
@9M9VZZZLiberal Democrat 11mos11MO
Racism in the UK isn't just about individuals being mean to another; it's built into our laws, institutions, and history. To tackle it, we need to understand how it works on a bigger scale. That's where Critical Race Theory (CRT) comes in. It helps us see how racism is woven into our society. By teaching CRT in schools, we can help kids understand racism better and work towards making things fairer for everyone.
@9HP3ZXV1yr1Y
We cannot fully integrate into a society if we are taught to dislike each other based on what our ancestors did
@9FMN3XY2yrs2Y
Our institutions, laws and history are not inherently racist. We should raise childre to be colourblind and view everyone in the world as equals, regardless of skin colour.
@9M2MF9N11mos11MO
It is unproductive to think we cannot ACHIEVE anything until racism has ended. We should teach children that working hard will help them to overcome all barriers in life, which may include racism. We cannot end racism but it doesn't define us either..
@ISIDEWITH4yrs4Y
Yes, and also add Intersectionality and the 1619 Project to the curriculum
@9FCJK6X2yrs2Y
These programs are political dogma disguised as virtue. They offer no benefit to people and just seek to portray a protracted and narrow view on racial issues.
@9F7WN42Conservative2yrs2Y
Critical Race Theory is a neo-Marxist lens through which to view the world which is intended to stoke division and lead to revolution. Absolutely it should NOT be taught.
@ISIDEWITH4yrs4Y
Yes, but not until they are teenagers
@9MY77LF10mos10MO
Critical Race Theory is a complex academic legal theory that is not, and cannot be, taught to children of school age. The idea that it is being taught is a lie perpetuated by those with an agenda to undermine equality initiatives.
@98HD5YB2yrs2Y
Critical race theory isn’t being taught in schools, the history of slavery within the British empire is, critical race theory is a high level legal theory learned in universities and similar institutions not in primary or secondary schools.
@9LJQZFJ12mos12MO
So you think we should teach our children that Britain was the first country in world history to end slavery. Give all our children something to be proud of.
@9G9L3GP1yr1Y
yes critical race theories should be taught in universities. free games
@9PKWB269mos9MO
It should be acknowledged and taught, but so should other race theories as well, and opposing points to it should be taught too.
@9KXH357Conservative1yr1Y
No, telling whites children they are inherently racist is not only racist in itself but also increases the likelihood of those children being racist in the future. Racism exists against all cultures and therefore only awareness is required. People need to be less sensitive and move on.
@8PJPT294yrs4Y
Everyone no matter what color of their skin should be treated equally and fairly. Intersectionality and tribalism worsens bigotry yet also add working class history to the curriculim. Also, focus on that our institutions, laws and history are inherently racist and classist.
Yes, but only in secondary schools
@8LWFNLX4yrs4Y
Yes, but in a way that demonstrates how we can learn from our mistakes and move forward into a more just society without stirring a hatred between races
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
Imagine a classroom without discussions on race—how does this compare to one that openly talks about racial issues, and what are the potential outcomes of each?
@9H8K4691yr1Y
In a classroom it should be more important about the person, not their race. It encourages people of races other than Caucasian to think of themselves as different which promotes a unfair society
@93T6D3B3yrs3Y
No , CRT is a lie and should not be taught as it is based on the misconception white people are inherently racist
@8NND6Q24yrs4Y
Not all laws and history are racist and nobody is born racist, so acceptance should be taught as well as historical mistakes
@8M839PC4yrs4Y
Students should be informed of racism and racism in institutions and history but that it is wrong and everybody should be treated equally regardless of race
@8M74R8H4yrs4Y
Yes as long as it educates from both sides and not just from one perspective. This then avoids racism on both sides within the teaching of it
@9F58ZK42yrs2Y
This is stupid: Critical Race Theory is a university level topic. It's like asking if quantum theory should be taught in nursery.
No, critical race theory shouldn't be taught in schools, because it is university level. However yes basic racial equality practices should be used in the education system.
@92SK98V3yrs3Y
Critical race theory is a graduate level theory and deeply inappropriate for school-aged children to be taught. Nonetheless, awareness of racism in British society, and anti-racist ideas should be part of a school's ethos.
@92LWBFC3yrs3Y
CRT is a university level course and is not taught at any primary or secondary school levels. Racism and other social issues should be taught but this is not teaching CRT.
@8YL937W3yrs3Y
No, racism is simply a "woke" idea pedalled by the National Trust for political purposes
@8VZVFZK4yrs4Y
Kids should be taught to be proud of their race
@8VZNPP54yrs4Y
It depends on age. Older students need to understand institutionalised racism in order to fight against it. Younger students need to be taught that the colour of someone's skin does not make them better/worse than someone else.
@8TLN4VT4yrs4Y
Yes - to understand our racist history and to prevent it in the future - but also no, as kids should be raised as racially colour blind.
@8TJNTNQ4yrs4Y
Yes, but not until they are teenagers, also add Intersectionality and the 1619 Project to the curriculum and we cannot end racism until we acknowledge that our institutions, laws, and history are inherently racist
@B45V8QF6 days6D
Yes, but CRT is a university level course, that isnt even taught to primary or secondary schoolers!!!
@B444TX21wk1W
Teach students an honest and balanced account of history, including racism and inequality, but without framing individuals as inherently privileged or oppressed. Focus on shared civic values, critical thinking, and the importance of treating others with dignity and fairness.
@B42NTFT1wk1W
They should not teach them that they are racist or disadvantaged but they should inform people of the past
@B3YL86Q2wks2W
No, but students should receive cultural education so they are able to operate with more awareness and empathy towards their peers and others around them, as well as have a greater understanding of humanity.
@B3TC4GM3wks3W
When they are kids, lessons about equality should be taught i.e.; being nice to one another no matter how different you look, as the children progress and get older, more history should be incorporated into lesson planning.
@B3NP2BF3wks3W
Racial, gender, and religious issues should be taught as part of a balanced perspective with the aim being mainly to teach children critical thinking and kindness.
I think kids should be raised racially colour blind so that they do not grow up with ingrained prejudice against people, but perhaps in the older years of secondary school this should be taught, along with Intersectionality and the 1619 Project. After all, we cannot truly end racism until we acknowledge that our institutions, laws and history are inherently racist, understand why, and rethink them more inclusively.
Teach children eugenics and racial history to learn about where they come from wnd how much their ancestors committed to the world we live in today instead of this anti white propaganda
@B34TFWGIndependent1mo1MO
it should not be taught that law and institutions are inherently racist because that undermines all of the progress we have done to remove them, instead we should teach children that we once we racist but now we are free and we have made progress to remove those racist laws but we should not down play racism and we should tell children or teenagers the full truth of how minority's were treated and abused in America.
@B2YGD5ZWomen's Equality2mos2MO
Critical race theory is advanced sociopolitical theory, the related topics should be taught at all ages but the specific theory itself is more university level.
@B2RN7JCLiberal Democrat 2mos2MO
Yes but not in the sense where children believe they should be racist or that everyone around them is racist only that certain people for example those in positions of power who run institutions. It’s also a risk of non white children feeling as though their life is determined which is limited.
@B2NNXSZ2mos2MO
teaching of critical race theory throughout history is important, we cannot look to the future if we are going to make the same mistakes of the past.
@B2HR5282mos2MO
yes, but be careful about how it is taught so people don't think they are at a disadvantage or inherently racist
@B2GK4342mos2MO
Yes in secondary as primary school children may not be able to fully understand and appreciate the topics
@B2D7YYF3mos3MO
I think that children should be taught about race and what race they are but still to treat everyone the same
@B2CVMSL3mos3MO
Teaching children that their skin colour makes them either a racist or a victim is poor form and is not a good way to teach anyone. We’re all just people living in the present, regardless of the atrocities of the past.
@B28Z62B3mos3MO
In case of primary school, casual and learned racism should be corrected, but the topic should be taught when they reach secondary school, as they’re more likely to grasp the subject
@B26KWF2 3mos3MO
Yes. However it is important to understand capitalism is the root of this evil and to teach and to understand it. It should be taught as a teenager. Racism exists because of capitalism.
No, should avoid direct criticism of general people, advocate for unifying against hatred and prejudice.
@9ZYQSNF4mos4MO
yes to make them more aware until they are in year 9 or 10 when ever the school start teaching gse this is so they are aware and it doesn't take time out of there gse
@9ZX58R64mos4MO
Critical race theory is a university level concept, but they should be taught about structural racism and colonialism
@9ZJ6JSZ5mos5MO
Only as part of a range of theories/approaches to be explored, evaluated and discussed in secondary school
@9ZCWX4H5mos5MO
Primary age should not be “taught” specifically, but it could be mentioned if relevant to another topic Secondary age can go in to more detail
@9YN6HZP5mos5MO
It should be addressed that minorities are disproportionately affected by turmoil in a country; especially economically.
@9Y7YLT75mos5MO
It depends on the parents opinion, not to force all children to have one type of opinion (it can be bad depending on the teacher)
@9XDM9865mos5MO
Yes, add the intersectionality and 1619 project to the curriculum and only do it until they are teenagers.
@9XC9KSF5mos5MO
It is a framework that can be explored, but it is not the standard, it's so complicated it would only be able to be taught in secondary school.
@9WN2ZSH5mos5MO
Yes, taught in secondary schools but a permission slip from a parent/guardian be required in primary schools.
@9W7YDWR5mos5MO
Should not be taught to primary schools too young unless issues come up, you do not want some children to feel disadvantaged but in secondary school it is valid as racial colourblindness wears off with age
The problem with this CRT narrative is that it has lost its entire meaning because of conservatives. CRT is a college level dialectic. It might be too advanced for kids, but I think that basics of CRT should be taught. It just depends on what we're actually talking about
@9VTRVL36mos6MO
I don't think it makes much difference to teach it to people because it shouldn't still be in affect but I'm not an expert so if the government is institutionally racist than it can't hurt to make children aware
@9TTR23T6mos6MO
Yes but should be taught with the right language for the younger years and it should be taught from year 5 no younger
@9SM3J2L7mos7MO
Yes, its a valid mainstream theory that should be taught alongside many others with the tools for children to debate and analyze them.
@9SBTMJP7mos7MO
Yes in citizenship lessons at GCSEs, and learn to scrutinise the history of Britain, reducing racism.
@9R53PZ28mos8MO
I do not support it personally but allow individual schools the choice to decide if they want to teach it or not
@9QYR3MW9mos9MO
Critical race theory itself is a complex framework best reserved for relevant A-level and university coursework. However, primary and secondary school curricula should be informed by Critical Race Theory.
@9QXNYG39mos9MO
I think it should only be taught in later secondary school and stressed that it is a theory and not every organisation is like this
@9QSW5F59mos9MO
No because it is a complex university level theory, elements of it can be filtered down though as there as important learnings from it
@9QSCSHJ9mos9MO
Anti-racism should be taught but CRT as a whole is not appropriate for the UK's context. Schools can choose to teach it if they wish.
@9QSC8CY9mos9MO
Given literal critical race theory is a part of uni level legal studies, it's not really clear to most people what this means.
@9QRYSLS9mos9MO
It is important to have these conversations to bring awareness to these areas with the idea to prevent current and future racism.
@9QR28SH9mos9MO
No, this is a valuable topic but it is taught at a post-graduate level topic, none of its advocates are seriously suggesting it because brought into schools.
@9QQG4W29mos9MO
Teach about the overt racism and institutional racism that exists and has existed in the past without relying on a politicized curriculum.
@9QQ7RBQ9mos9MO
they should be taught basics with inclusive activities to reduce racism but do not go into complicated details.
@9QPYNDF9mos9MO
Society is more Woke than ever, we should be teaching not to discriminate with hate, pulling children and adults up on every minor thing that is said is not useful, teach people to not say thing with malace and to not take everything personally and as a personal hatred.
@9QPB8K29mos9MO
The education content needs a current day re - vamp to bring us all forward in the right direction. How to manage money efficiently, Goals , methods , what is a mortgage ? & what’s the process? Cooking skills & Good moral teachings of life & how to approach the right way 💯
@9QNTX8T9mos9MO
Only if parental guardian consents to there child viewing/ learning about racist views and prejudice
@9QNQ3SD9mos9MO
Matters pertaining to racism, discrimination and prejudice should be taught in schools, and this should be linked to events in history. We should not encourage people to think they are more advantaged/ disadvantaged due to the colour of the their skin. This shouldn’t be promoted.
@9QNNYDM9mos9MO
Yes, but this should be presented in a debate style where teenage students can start to explore solutions and not dwell on the discrimination to the point it creates excessive divides and tension
@9QNJ8V59mos9MO
People should be taught accurately and truthfully about the past but it should not be taught as if integral to current society.
@93MNLQ3 9mos9MO
Yes, but it needs to be very carefully considered on how it is approached. Rushing it could be more damaging to children.
@9QLZC3BLiberal Democrat9mos9MO
Yes, in order for children to be raised in a functioning society that sees all as equals, it is vital that historical references be clarified as to the perspective from time period and how that relates to present day
@9QKZ9TH9mos9MO
Kids should be taught to respect their heritage so that race is not seen as a a barrier to learn about how humanity evolved. One race can not be superiour to another is the central message.
@9QKKXV59mos9MO
Kids are only racist because they have been brought up thta way it is learnt behaviour! Teach the adults
@9QKJPK39mos9MO
I believe they should be taught the correct history but it needs to not turn into hatred towards other races
@9QKDMMC9mos9MO
Yes it should be taught, but it should not be taught as fact; it is a “theory” after all and we should be taught to either support or critique it through a balanced lens, casting a “critical” eye!
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.