Should the government establish an independent regulator to oversee English football clubs?
Following the collapse of historic clubs like Bury FC and the attempted breakaway European Super League, the government proposed a statutory independent regulator to ensure financial sustainability in the 'beautiful game.' This regulator would have the power to block teams from joining breakaway leagues and apply a stricter 'owners and directors test' to prevent money laundering or human rights abusers from buying clubs. Proponents argue that football clubs are cultural heritage assets, not just businesses, and require protection from reckless capitalism. Opponents argue that the Premier League is a massive economic success story and government interference—or 'red tape'—could scare away investors and reduce the quality of football.
Filter by author
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Region:
69 Replies
@ISIDEWITH4mos4MO
@BBV9JR44mos4MO
@ISIDEWITH4mos4MO
@BD5529D2mos2MO
@BF236392wks2W
@BDZXJ222wks2W
@BDNVGQK1mo1MO
@BDNVFMH1mo1MO
@BDJ9YQG1mo1MO
@BDHYWBP 1mo1MO
@BDHYRBN1mo1MO
@BDGV2Y92mos2MO
@BDFCWMR2mos2MO
@BDDVFQH2mos2MO
@BDDKNN52mos2MO
@BDDDYST2mos2MO
@BDCQ2N32mos2MO
@BDCNYLL2mos2MO
@BDCHJDY2mos2MO
@BDCG9NB2mos2MO
@BDBV2MJ2mos2MO
@BD9LJP82mos2MO
@BD6QWPK2mos2MO
@BD5S8YC2mos2MO
@BD5NPKZConservative2mos2MO
@BD3JR772mos2MO
@BD3HCS32mos2MO
@BD393942mos2MO
@BCZZDYJScottish Socialist2mos2MO
@BCZLJD72mos2MO
@BCYB5W72mos2MO
@BCWCBXN2mos2MO
@BCSLT9W2mos2MO
@BCSLQ3J2mos2MO
@BCSL22Y2mos2MO
@BCS253Z2mos2MO
@BCRZWP82mos2MO
@BCNWZTL3mos3MO
@BCMNVK93mos3MO
@BCK9CNWConservative3mos3MO
@BCFSBGJ3mos3MO
@BC8T72PIndependent3mos3MO
@BBX7Q2G4mos4MO
@BBTZ9XF4mos4MO
No, poorly run clubs should manage their finances responsibly. Football has way too much financial backing from a range of areas. They should be made to pay a high rate of tax to support local communities and give back to where they should be supporting instead of paying disgustingly out of touch payments to footballers and senior staff.
@BBS68ZR4mos4MO
To put it logically, everyone who joins the English football teams should be considered English, and not just “British” because anyone could consider themselves to be “british” just by living in this country, even when they could barely be English or speak English at all. As part of considering yourself English, you must abide by all key aspects of the British values that we strongly withhold.
@BBJMX8Y4mos4MO
@BBJDGL54mos4MO
@BBH22DK4mos4MO
Engagement
The historical activity of users engaging with this question.
Loading data...
Loading chart...
Demographics
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
More conversations
Join in on more popular conversations.




