In 2004 the government passed the Hunting Act which banned the practice of hunting mammals with dogs in England and Wales. The Act allows dogs to sniff out foxes but bans them from killing. The Act does not prevent hunters from using dogs to “drag hunt" which uses dogs to track and sniff out foxes. Proponents argue that fox hunting with dogs is a time honored tradition that supports rural communities. Opponents argue that killing foxes with dogs is cruel since the hunted animals suffer severe physiological and psychological stress during the hunt - whether they are killed or not.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Political theme:
Political party:
@9P7FQK710mos10MO
No and the practice should be explicitly illegal with no loopholes such as trail hunting. It is out dated and has no place in modern society.
@9PWDD5L 9mos9MO
Yes but you should require a hunting permit and issue quotas for the amount of foxes that are allowed to be hunted by a person within a year
@9NMKFSQ10mos10MO
No. But individuals whose poultry/livestock are damaged by foxes should not be punished for hunting down said fox with a dog as long as it is not exposed to undue suffering.
@9P6LYBDConservative10mos10MO
No, it's cruel, if there is an issue with foxes in an area then the natural predator of the fox should be introduced
@92FC2LM3yrs3Y
No but farmers should continue to shoot foxes for being threats to their livelihoods
@9CCX4X42yrs2Y
Yes, provided it is regulated and does not endanger the fox population from overuse.
@8HHDC2D4yrs4Y
@8FP2G654yrs4Y
Regardless, this is a matter of culture and should not be influenced by government
@9TNG7SCAnimal Welfare6mos6MO
I think that there should be a limit to what dogs can hunt. For example, dogs can hunt birds and pheasants but not animals such as foxes, sheep ect.
@9T3DSPH7mos7MO
If the foxes and Dogs have deadly diseases such as Rabies or if they are severely affect agriculture then it is fine in my opinion, however for entertainment purposes I believe it is extremely wrong
@9QLRN2L9mos9MO
Hunting should only be permitted in any case where the local ecology supports it. Fox populations are currently not in a position to support hunting for sport, and neither are deer populations managed in a way which supports the environment in Scotland. It should not be an offence to kill either animal but it should not be encouraged or legal as a sport
Yes, to an extent if it is to control the population of foxes, but it shouldn’t be allowed simply for a pleasurable pastime
@9QJB5RR9mos9MO
No, it is cruel, tradition can be upheld with ‘clean boot’ hunts and the current laws should be enforced properly
@9QFDS8L9mos9MO
Foxes are no longer hunted with dogs since the hunting ban. Cleanboot and drag hunting should not be banned as this will lead to the death of thousands of dogs and horses and the loss of livelihood of hundreds of people who hugely help protect our environment
@9QBL4X49mos9MO
Must be atheist by the famers and make sure the roads. Do T agree but let's do it safe . Munck jack running is going to kill me and the mini jack ., indjnt fancy dieing today deer and a banger flip.ped us over .
@9Q99JZ69mos9MO
Those involved in the chase should have to pay compensation to the residents of involved properties and land.
@9PN737T9mos9MO
I disagree with actively hunting foxes but think planned scent hunts should still be allowed. It’s such a big part of English heritage and should not be lost completely.
@9PLD7KD9mos9MO
I support getting rid of foxes humanely...I have lost many chicken to the fox...but not by being ripped apart by dogs...a single shot is far more humane
@9PKBMH59mos9MO
As long as it is regulated to ensure that it doesn’t risk extinction population levels of the animals
@9P64R6J10mos10MO
I do hunt but fear that if brought back in non hunters will cause alot more problems and currently the hunts illegally kill
@9P2ZXVZ10mos10MO
No, the actual hunting of foxes should remain illegal however trail hunts that are monitored to be performing legally should be allowed
@9MV38MK10mos10MO
no but culling Urban foxes should be legalised through a reputable firm - like the deer cull in Richmond Park
@9LQH3MDConservative11mos11MO
But we should have oversight and recourse to take action if foxes/badger etc numbers increase to the extent that ut is detrimental to livestock. Then the government should step in to control numbers. I do not agree with fox hunting because it is a tradition.
@9LFPJP412mos12MO
Only where there is a limit on the number of dogs in use at any time and the dog is only used to chase foxes out of their homes where they have been known to attack local farmstock.
@9KQLQMS 1yr1Y
I don't support the act of the sport itself but I do support the right for farmers etc to protect their live stock if threatened.
@9KB42571yr1Y
Kinda depand if you're grabbing foxs then releasing them to hunt OR hunting them because there a problem
@9K8XQT61yr1Y
No. Encourage the tradition to be done with willing human volunteers if they still want to participate in the tradition.
@9HJHSRR1yr1Y
Yes, but only if it’s for tradition and done in a way that’s responsible and doesn’t cause the foxes much suffering
Dont really care either way, however foxes should be kept under control as they can carry disease and can destroy habitat
@9H7H6RQ1yr1Y
No, it should remain illegal and furthermore, drag hunting should be monitored more since it is often used as a smokescreen for illegal fox hunting.
@9H64RDP1yr1Y
Yes, only if it's done to control the population of foxes to prevent destabilisation in the ecosystem.
@9GZSCZP1yr1Y
No. I support the hunting of animals such as rabbits with the intention to eat them. Hunting foxes is merely a sport and I do not support it.
@9GBPQFL 1yr1Y
Yes, it is cruel. It should only be carried out in a harmless manner if there is an overpopulation issue. It should not be a sport.
@9FNLFYB2yrs2Y
It should be regulated heavily
@9FHT42G2yrs2Y
rural foxes should be removed and put in their natural habitats instead of at risk of harm to us and them
@9FD22552yrs2Y
yes, only if a person needs to survive, out of spite should not be recommended
@9DVNJBXConservative2yrs2Y
It isnt nice, however it is a tradition, maybe a middle ground in which foxes could be bread for hunting purposes, similar to game shoots.
@9DMBP7Y2yrs2Y
@9DM4FG92yrs2Y
I don't support it but wouldn't stop others doing it
@9P9D9VN10mos10MO
I support up until the fox goes to go ground , the fox at this point has won and should not be dug or driven out by terriers
@9NS7VWY10mos10MO
It is a tradition. However, mainly taken up by those in the higher income bracket. Foxes are considered vermin in certain areas as they attack farms. This is a form of pest control. However, the use of dogs to kill the foxes can be seen as barbaric and more humane ways should be considered.
@9NQQGQZ10mos10MO
No, but I support the hunting of a human quarry with bloodhounds or packs following an artificial scent that bears no relation to wildlife.
@9NDMYLLConservative10mos10MO
Yes but undertaken within the law. For example, flushed by dogs and then killed humanely via a bird of prey/gun NOT ripped to shreds by a dog 5 miles later
@9N425C710mos10MO
I don't mind the horses and the dogs, as long as they don't kill or hunt foxes. I support the hunt if they ate using a person but pretending to be fox and they hunt that way.
@9N2QTND10mos10MO
I agree with drag hunting as a traditional sport but the hounds need to be trained to scents away from foxes and be muzzled to prevent incidents of foxes being killed by hounds
@9N2MP7310mos10MO
Yes, it is a tradition of rural communities but there should be a closer look at the treatment of the foxes, if they are killed quickly and with limited suffering
@9MXZ75J10mos10MO
Yes, this is a tradition that supports rural communities. But should only be done if foxs are over populated in the area or becoming an issue
@9MWWNMJ10mos10MO
If hunting foxes with dogs is cruel, so is allowing a pet cat out to roam and kill birds, mice, shrews etc.
@9GJ4MT71yr1Y
I support people hunting foxes for sport or because of tradition but not with dogs as it is a less skilled and more brutal way of hunting
@96794Z52yrs2Y
Imprison those for murder who do it
No, Hunt the human tories instead
@9PGJZTT9mos9MO
I live in the countryside, and fox hunts are still happening in rishis constituency! They are wearing, cruel and do NOT help control fox populations. Most foxes live in towns and cities not anyway!
@9PGDV769mos9MO
Yes, public or not, it is required as a planned cull of foxes, which for farmers and livestock owners are vermin just the same as rats
@9BTX9Z72yrs2Y
Fox Hunting should only be done when foxes become pests
@9BRZ48S2yrs2Y
Leave it up to the farmers
@9BR2B4G2yrs2Y
not really sure to be honest
@99YKL3H2yrs2Y
Fox's that destroy infrastructure should be shot. Same for badger's with TB.
@96NRRJLConservative2yrs2Y
Yes, however only in areas where it is necessary for foxes to be culled due to overpopulation and distraction of the surrounding environment.
@96NKCK72yrs2Y
No, but foxes need managing
No, and the ban should actually be enforced
@95YPGKDPlaid Cymru3yrs3Y
Not with dogs, yes with rifles
@95YLM8H3yrs3Y
Yes, but it should be licensed on an individual basis with strict background checks made.
@95VVVWV3yrs3Y
Yes, but as long as the practice is environmentally sustainable
@95L3BGB3yrs3Y
Only when overpopulation affects the biodiversity of the ecosystem
@95BJZRH3yrs3Y
No, this is a barbaric practice and should be banned everywhere in the UK.
@946X2G6Conservative3yrs3Y
Fake/Trail hunts should still be allowed but actually hunting should remain banned.
@946GS7Y3yrs3Y
Yes as long as dogs are used to flush the fox and not kill
Yes, but only if proof that fox populations are out of control, not as sport.
@93VCB7P3yrs3Y
Yes, but the practice should be regulated so to not harm indigenous fox populations
@93SDWTB3yrs3Y
I think the fox hunters should be hunted. Killing for pleasure is not someone beneficial to society
@93Q3QZ33yrs3Y
No, not real foxes but have nothing against the fake fox hunts
@92N9SSS3yrs3Y
Small quantity of foxes are killed each year and they are vermin.
@92FYM3X3yrs3Y
Heavily restrict hunting but don't completely ban it
@92FWQVVLiberal Democrat3yrs3Y
Yes, if it is done with only two dogs used to flush the fox.
@929C4T93yrs3Y
If the foxes pose threat to a farmers crops and that fox population should be measured
@9267QF73yrs3Y
Only in the case where foxes are damaging local farms/ecosystem and not excessively
@8ZWQ68RLibertarian3yrs3Y
No, hunting with a dog is pathetic unless using it for tracking or retrieval of the carcass, I support hunting when a person kills the animal themselves
@8ZSHLN83yrs3Y
Should be up to individual communties.
@8ZNL4RH3yrs3Y
No how will we ever find out what the fox says?
@8ZLKHR53yrs3Y
No, but try to support some of the traditions around it.
@8ZDK8DJ3yrs3Y
In some circumstances this would be okay
@8Z335LC3yrs3Y
Yes, as long as no foxes are killed
@8YV2VLS3yrs3Y
Yes, but only to reduce over population.
@8YTYF58Liberal Democrat3yrs3Y
yes, only if there is no fox involved and a man-made scent should be followed
@8YMV9DS3yrs3Y
No, This messes with the Ecological balance.
@8YKWK783yrs3Y
Tolerate it but dont support it
@8YK67Z83yrs3Y
No, and ban trail hunting
@8YDDRD73yrs3Y
Never for fun but if they are causing problems then only until sorted
@8YCBCF53yrs3Y
No,, but it shouldn't be banned.
@8VZ6S9Z4yrs4Y
Yes but it should have a lot of oversight to make sure it’s not effecting population numbers
@8VYLJHRConservative4yrs4Y
Yes, I think that there is a balance to be struck. Hunting groups should be allowed as the current system and in some cases where population control warrants.
@8VYK5VR4yrs4Y
Yes but the fox must live or be killed humanly with a gun no dogs ripping it apart
@8VSY84L4yrs4Y
Whilst I wouldn’t support hunting personally, I think cheap meat and poor animal welfare affects far more animals and gas implications for both animal and human health and welfare
Things would currently stay as they are, unless a petition was successful in reversing the ban.
@8VMSYZP4yrs4Y
All hunting of animals should be banned.
Whilst this is a culturally and geographically relative act, it is a practice formally enacted upon by particular quantiles of society. Moreover, it is seen as an act of animal cruelty by the greater swathes of the population and studies have found that foxes are, behaviourally, friendly and of no threat to the human population. This is not an act of sustenance, as seen in other hunting methods found in indigenous and rural communities, but is seen as an act of unnecessary cruelty. It is also at the centrifuge of class politics.
@8VJT4QW4yrs4Y
No, but support hunting of invasive species.
@8VHC6T54yrs4Y
Legal as long as the fox doesn’t die
No, and the police need to do more to enforce current laws and stricter punishments for those that break it
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.