Should the UK increase or decrease the amount of temporary work visas given to high-skilled immigrant workers?
Between 2008 and 2010 the United Kingdom began implementing a five tiered “points-based immigration system” which separated immigrant applicants into five tiers based on their employment potential. To secure a skilled worker visa, people have to qualify for 70 points. Having a job offer from an approved employer for a skilled job and being able to speak English will give 50 points. The applicant can achieve the remaining 20 points if they are due to be paid at least £25,600 a year. They can also gain extra points for having better qualifications (10 points for a relevant…
Read moreNarrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Discussions from these authors are shown:
Political party:
@8NVH2JB4yrs4Y
Increase but with protections to ensure wages are not decreased and at the same time increase funding for training citizens for high skill jobs.
@5492YBK4yrs4Y
UK companies should have to employ indigneous first
@9QGYZLQ9mos9MO
It should be case by case and only if the skill set is not in the UK. Further education to get the right skills in the UK in the first place. Higher immigration for people who work for less money pushes down wages for everyone else
@9QGNHDH9mos9MO
Pay everyone a decent wage and it won't matter where they come from. The UK should be the gold standard by which other countries emulate. We also need to buy ethically but until there is equitable pay across the global chain of production then this will always create imbalance between what we get and what we can have. It should not be a struggle for the basics. Bit by bit affordability of the basics have become more and more a luxury.
@9QF6QB59mos9MO
Increase high skill like doctors but still provide incentives for British born citizens to work those jobs also, free university education would help motivate more young people to aspire for high skilled jobs
@9Q8SS3GWomen's Equality9mos9MO
I think we should allow it for doctors and nhs workers as their is so many jobs that need filling - however we need to restart the benefits system and make sure that we are making our own citezens work in the uk - if we make sure that every uk born citizen is working after education, then it would solve this issue anyway
@9Q8H64T9mos9MO
Increase, it should be easier to work in the UK, but companies should not be used to decrease wages for everyone else.
@9Q7M2K7Liberal Democrat9mos9MO
As above - we shouldn’t only be allowing skilled workers into the uk? We need unskilled labour as well
@9Q6FJ659mos9MO
Depends on skill, Criminal record, fluency in the language and culture, or actually willing to learn
@9Q4TBTB9mos9MO
Increase because we benefit from different types of experience and education. They should be paid the same as UK cutizens
@9Q2CBXC9mos9MO
Yes for roles where needed but monitored, reviewed and not with automatic‘forever’. And which a plan for filling the gap
@9PDZP8Z10mos10MO
Free movement for a free country, it's possible to control this with the right people in charge, demented governments should not be in charge of immigration
Should the UK increase or decrease the amount of temporary work visas given to high-skilled immigrant workers based on demand.
@9P6Z8KN10mos10MO
Maintain visas for skilled workers in vocations that have national shortages however ensure skilled workers are qualified or experienced in the field they are obtaining a visa foe.
@9NY6RNL10mos10MO
Provide incentives to prepare our citizens for these jobs, but increase to fit needs of the economy until the former plugs all the gaps.
Increase at the moment to solve labour shortages in areas such as farming, but re-join the EU as a longer term solution. Be guided by need, not dog-whistle politics.
@9NGP4CYConservative10mos10MO
Increase in relevant professional areas: doctors, nurses etc ensuring they have great English and good bedside manner
@9N87MZC10mos10MO
We should encourage companies to take on the Uk university graduates who at the minute are all struggling to find jobs regardless of their degree type. Their education has been paid for, it should be put to use.
@9N5FDKQ10mos10MO
Adopt the Australian method of accepting skilled workers for a particular job when there is a shortage
@9N3CRHW10mos10MO
Agree - our economy does rely on businesses employing highly skilled individuals from other areas of the world. Should they be paid less? No! Equally providing hospitalities to immigrants who provide nothing to the countries economy is extremely counter productive and significantly devalues the argument increasing the number of temporary work visas.
@9M2LWYT11mos11MO
What a stupid question. Throw the morons who live outside of the M25 into the ocean and bring more immigrants in. The Brits are the dumbest and most useless part of the UK.
@9KVPYF31yr1Y
Remain same and increase the training and education of national youth to fulfill the areas of expertise
@9KGYRMXConservative1yr1Y
If we need specific workers with specific qualifications, and we cannot supply them internally, we should outsource with immigrants.
@9JDYRQZ1yr1Y
Equal pay to if they were from this country originally, to limit Wage exploitation but to also combat zenophobia
@9GZYTRX1yr1Y
Its bad to use high skilled workers and immigrants and give them low paying jobs in exchange for their high skills. People travel to the UK for a better chance at life therefore they shiould be able to get that opportunity
@B25L8JS4mos4MO
Yes increase but the uk is full, deport the parasite immigrants and replace them with the skilled ones that want to be in our society
@9MZ4T2610mos10MO
We should stop wasting time with the bureaucracy of temporary visas and just allow more permanent immigration by anyone
The visas should not be temporary, if we benefit from a person’s skills they should benefit from being here
@9LQYFCK11mos11MO
This should be a decrease but in the right way. We should promote an elite level of workforce with free immigration it makes up the backbone of the country.
@9LGRV7D12mos12MO
Temporary Visas are heavily abused and result in slavery-like conditions for workers and should be more heavily regulated and sponsors be inspected more frequently.
@9FJNLJH2yrs2Y
Depedent upon labour supply in different sectord
@9FCRMPLLibertarian2yrs2Y
Honestly never thought about it
@9BVNCV22yrs2Y
we should but also add strict rules incase people try to take advantage of this programe
@96PHRYW2yrs2Y
Decrease but make more permanent opportunities for skilled workers to become citizens
@94JPB6W3yrs3Y
increase on the jobs with the most vaccancys
@8Z5T89C3yrs3Y
The government should also provode more incentives to prepare our citizens for these jobs. They should increase in areas where there is a labour shortage but they should provide a fair wage to anyone.
@8WJQF2K3yrs3Y
Increase where we are short of people
@8RB2SCD4yrs4Y
Decrease, but increase the amount if permanent work visas instead.
@8Q99R494yrs4Y
Increase if needed and wages should not be lower.
@8Q8P9WS4yrs4Y
Increase. However, we should also prepare and ensure our own citizens are prepared for these roles.
@8Q5Q4XJ4yrs4Y
depends on terrorism level after banning immigration for a while
@8Q4TL6YLiberal Democrat4yrs4Y
Do whatever the job market requires. There is also the thought around having more young people living in the country paying taxes = more money to help the people depending on the state helping them i.e. elderly
@8Q3LQB84yrs4Y
In order to achieve economic growth then increase but to increase development decrease and improve supply side policies
@8Q3HP5MConservative4yrs4Y
We should operate a system where an employer has to prove the role can't be filled in country before employing out with.
@8Q34FVY4yrs4Y
Too complicated to answer with one sentence
Increase, but maintaining fair wages
@8LT2B5C4yrs4Y
No borders, no nations, no deportations
@8KL56H74yrs4Y
Decrease, but give to those where the sector is in need of labour.
@8K6YGZ34yrs4Y
We should try to hire from our own residents first and initiate schemes to support and encourage our own residents into these roles. where there are still not sufficient workers to fill the roles, visas should be offered to residents from other countries
@8C723Z85yrs5Y
@9BTX993Conservative2yrs2Y
Increase in essential areas, but invest in training and employment programs so that UK citizens can fill these jobs too and reduce domestic unemployment
@9BSWB9X2yrs2Y
Increase but with a view to education and fill these gaps with home grown talent in future
@9BRRGVW2yrs2Y
Increase for skilled workers where there is big lack in that industry
@9BD2ZM5Conservative2yrs2Y
Increase but as long as they have been thoroughly checked out first
Depends on the sector of business
@99H48LW2yrs2Y
The number issued should be proportional to the number required.
@98WS7R22yrs2Y
Decrease, work visas only exist for cheap labour, stealing workers from impoverished countries and forcing them to work for less than a UK citizen.
@98FVPZR2yrs2Y
They should keep it the same.
@985XZT72yrs2Y
Increase for now, but reform the education system to better produce our own skilled workers for the future
@983Z9S92yrs2Y
Give all the foreigners the death penalty
@97ZKKNF2yrs2Y
Don’t know what this means.
@8SJ8GGG4yrs4Y
Demand should influence numbers whether for skilled or unskilled workers. All should have a job available at point of entry with a point of departure where appropriate.
@B4CMWVJ21hrs21H
Increase but allow the people opportunities to get full time jobs with greater opportunities and don’t exploit them for cheaper pay
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.