Felony disenfranchisement is the exclusion from voting of people otherwise eligible to vote due to conviction of a criminal offense, usually restricted to the more serious class of crimes deemed felonies. Prisoners cannot vote while in jail in India but can vote when they are released (even if they are convicted of a felony.)
Narrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Discussions from these authors are shown:
@4Y254FY4yrs4Y
Yes, except for felons convicted of electoral fraud
@9QLTD8MLiberal Democrat9mos9MO
If they are incarcerated no. If they have been released their conviction is spent and therefore should be allowed to vote providing they are not on bail.
@9PWBNRS9mos9MO
This should be for judges to decide on a case by case basis. Judges should decide whether or not forfeiture of the right to vote is an appropriate part of the punishment element of a sentence.
@9JZXTCG1yr1Y
Yes, but as long as it is not an extreme offence, and it has been 10 years since the crime was committed.
@9RT5H6HConservative8mos8MO
If they are due to be released within the next government term, otherwise not. Foreign-born criminals should lose their right to vote.
@9QPFWVY9mos9MO
Yes, unless in their trial they were proven to have a mental disorder which influenced them to commit the crime
@9QMNVLR9mos9MO
Yes, if they will be freed before the next election so they have a say in the society they return to.
@9PXJZ9S9mos9MO
Minor convictions should not lead to someone losing the right to vote. But if the conviction is something serious, then they perhaps should lose the right
@9N6LMBT10mos10MO
Yes, but only after they've been assessed mentally to show they’re capable of Making a stable and informed decision. However, if serving time no
@9M357CKWomen's Equality11mos11MO
Yes but where they are in a rehabilitation programme. I don't believe taking freedom and all basic rights from a human. This makes the situation worse and the person feeling hopeless. We need a reform of the way we manage criminals.
It varies on the charges but if they arent severe then yes because its the world they are living in but murderers and rapists deserve to die
@9FLBM822yrs2Y
Only if they have had a psych evaluation and have sane judgement
@9FJ2JQB2yrs2Y
Yes but their votes count less
If they’re sentence is less than a year
@8NR9HBDConservative4yrs4Y
Depends upon the crime committed.
@9BWPMLG2yrs2Y
Yes, if they have been assessed
@9BNFFQC2yrs2Y
no but only for the duration of their sentence
@9BMY27L2yrs2Y
yes, but not if the crime they committed was extremely violent and politically driven
@96P6ZMX2yrs2Y
Yes apart if they are a nonce
@96CS276Women's Equality2yrs2Y
only if they have changed
@963HQ3S2yrs2Y
Depending on the severity of the crime then I think that it could be decided that they have the right to vote as some criminals might turn their ways around.
@93W48DV3yrs3Y
Yes, but only those whose crimes were minor (under 5 years jail time) and they should not be allowed to vote on legislation which concerns their conviction
@93T4J723yrs3Y
Yes, except those with crimes against society.
@93L83673yrs3Y
Only if they will be allowed out of prison in their future lives.
@93L823Y3yrs3Y
@93JTJHS3yrs3Y
Yes, except for those convicted of financial crimes
Depends on the severity of their crime and their behaviour inside prison.
@92RM5KC3yrs3Y
Yes, if they are non-violent offenders and go through the polital voting capability from question 1
@92PJC7C3yrs3Y
Depends on the length of sentence and their crime.
@8W2PFK84yrs4Y
Yes, if they are due to be released in the course of the parliament being elected
@8RXT9KW4yrs4Y
yes but only if they would be out in public whilst that person was still in power
Yes, except for people who have committed heinous acts
@8RGCX2C4yrs4Y
I believe in Socrates idea of how democracy should be put in place
depending on the crimes severity
@8Q3LKL94yrs4Y
Yes but if they pass a mental capability test
@8Q39MDR4yrs4Y
@8PYPBDN4yrs4Y
i support a noocratic system
only if they will be coming out during that term
@8P6C45ZConservative4yrs4Y
Yes, but only if they are going to be released in that government's term
@8P4PX3Q4yrs4Y
Yes, but not while they are serving their time.
@8NXDYYV4yrs4Y
No, most citizens should not have the right to vote [generally]
@8KHQQJQ4yrs4Y
Yes, and give them access to political information, such as debates.
@8GZPZP44yrs4Y
Yes if they only committed petty crime
I support the use use of a modernised voter literacy test to determine individual voter's understanding of the issues and party positions they are voting for.
@8D8JF8V5yrs5Y
if it was a extremely violent hate crime towards a certain political or religious groups then no i do not believe they should be able to vote.
only after completing there sentences
@8CNWB965yrs5Y
if the felon has committed a hate crime or murder then i do not believe they have the right to vote, however if it is something simple, or something would not sway their vote, then of cource they should have the right just like any other citizen
@9CNY7JL2yrs2Y
Criminals haven’t done much for deserving but are still human
@9BVMRHHLiberal Democrat2yrs2Y
Yes, but only if they are in a sound mental state
@9BJDXS82yrs2Y
No, but only banned for a certain period of time.
@99D4T4L2yrs2Y
Depends on how bad the crime was for the person.
@98VN3592yrs2Y
It depends what the crime is, and if they've finished their sentence/parole
@98Q89ZRPlaid Cymru2yrs2Y
Yes, except for criminals convicted of terrorism or being involved with terrorist organisations.
@98KQRMH2yrs2Y
Yes, but only after completing their sentences and parole/probation however, if they re offend they get the right taken from them completely.
@98JVV672yrs2Y
Criminals, except for those convicted of murder, violent or sexual crimes, should be allowed to vote if they have the possibility of being released
@98JP6WB2yrs2Y
If they are of reasonable mental stability.
@98HQQ642yrs2Y
yes, but only if they have been proven sane
@987VTLJ2yrs2Y
Yes but only if their offence isn't too serious (such as GBH). However, cases such as: murder, sexual assault, kidnapping and extreme violence should not be allowed.
@97ZGC4ZLiberal Democrat2yrs2Y
Yes, however, it should be dependent upon the crime committed and they should be able to while serving a sentence, be it in prison, house arrest or probation
@97R7QHJAnimal Welfare2yrs2Y
Depends what the were imprisoned for
@96ZVJGT2yrs2Y
Yes, unless it was a horrific crime
@96GYHQP2yrs2Y
they should do a test to see how mentally stable they are
@944KCGM3yrs3Y
After their sentence or after a certain amount of time.
@93L84NF3yrs3Y
Only if they are found not to be a danger and are in a good state of mind.
@8RTTDQV4yrs4Y
Do not even slightly care
@8RGK6MZ4yrs4Y
If they've been out of parole for 30 years
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.