In 2019 Hungary elected Viktor Orban’s government and became the first EU country to be downgraded by the Freedom House organization to a “partly free” country. The organization labeled it a hybrid authoritarian regime that maintains formal democratic institutions but fails to meet the minimal standards for democracy.
Narrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Discussions from these authors are shown:
Political party:
Political party:
Borough:
@9FNVMTP1yr1Y
Up to own country not relevant
Yes but don't overly sanction, just make it clear that those governments are bad and remove some privileges.
@B386GW81mo1MO
No because most EU countries use the Euro so if you sanction an EU state that uses the Euro as well as you you do then you're doing damage to your own economy as the Euro using nations have a "shared economy" where if inflation in one Euro using state goes up, then all the other countries that use the Euro will also see an increase in inflation.
@9Q6V7VK9mos9MO
It depends… probably not as this will most likely encourage said country to remove further ties with EU
@9J8DHVX1yr1Y
Depends on the will of the people in said country. IF the EU were to offer a vote of no confidence to residents of the affected country and it was deemed the people do not want their government, then the EU could look into sanctions to "encourage" further democratisation of the member state.
@9FLR736 1yr1Y
Yes, but the sanctions should be carried out in a way that would not worsen our future relations with any countries that might come out of authoritarian governments.
@9FFWFFZ2yrs2Y
Depends on how well the economy is doing/how well the people are being treated
@9FC4P3H2yrs2Y
Only sanction governments that commit human rights abuse.
@9NGWVBWIndependent10mos10MO
Who decides what is authoritarian- we in Uk are lied to and manipulated rather than clear force - coercive control rather than brute force !
@96N6CX5Conservative2yrs2Y
I think every country should be looked at differently.
@96LN4TD2yrs2Y
I think they should be less inclined to help them
@96J75C32yrs2Y
Only if they are very very extreme and harmful to their citizens or a danger to other countries
Depends on the requirements to be defined as authoritarian
@9426QZ2Conservative3yrs3Y
Depends on whether they have broken international law or EU law that requires sanctions.
@93VGXT33yrs3Y
Yes, democracy should be protected and advocated for in all circumstances
@93576NL3yrs3Y
yes as well as remove them from the EU if they refuse to adjust their behaviour
@8ZW3GGHConservative3yrs3Y
Autocratic countries shouldn’t be allowed to join the EU
@8ZW39MHConservative3yrs3Y
Autocratic governments should not be allowed to join the EU
@8ZM5QTP3yrs3Y
Do not allow countries who are not liberal democracies into the EU
@8Z736C43yrs3Y
Provided the assessment is made/agreed upon by systems outside of the EU as well as the EU, yes.
@8VJG2PJ4yrs4Y
Why are they in the EU to begin with if they have authoritarian regimes?
@8TTXBF64yrs4Y
Yes, if the quality of their authoritarianism is sufficiently severe.
Don’t understand too much about this so I can’t really comment
@8S22YYB4yrs4Y
No, Countries with authoritarian government should not be in the EU
@8RZ4GL74yrs4Y
No, the term authoritarian is too broad
@8RWRFXH4yrs4Y
Abolish the EU Let individual countries sanction authoritarian governments
We've left the EU. It's none of our business.
@8PYT5RH4yrs4Y
It is not down to the European Union to decide who is Good, and who is bad.
@8JVPM224yrs4Y
The word “sanction” has two opposite meanings. It is sometimes used to mean “endorse”, and it is sometimes used to mean “enact measures like trade embargos, etc.”. The EU should not endorse authoritarian governments. The EU should strongly discourage authoritarian governments. More intelligent people than me should be carefully considering when it is appropriate to enact things like trade embargos against authoritarian governments.
@8G6KCWP4yrs4Y
Up to the individual countries
Don’t know enough about it.
@997MR3F2yrs2Y
If it doesn’t threaten the UK then No
@98TNBSL2yrs2Y
No, provided they have been democratically elected
@98S7TY42yrs2Y
Depends on how authoritarian is defined
@98MDYC42yrs2Y
if they are doing bad things in or out of country
@96R9QC7Liberal Democrat2yrs2Y
Only until a certain point of authoritarianism
@8Y29R9N3yrs3Y
Yes but not with any form of violence.
@8XXY7F9Liberal Democrat3yrs3Y
Yes but only once and should not make the final decision of what happens to the country.
@8XRM65M3yrs3Y
I not know enough about this topic
@8XHGMK33yrs3Y
do not know about this topic
@8PRV8CQ4yrs4Y
If the regime is causing harm
@9CG932R2yrs2Y
Yes, but only to the degree that their authoritarianism harms their people or violates European values.
@9C58J6G2yrs2Y
Allow nations within the EU who have different governments from another to thrive as they wish, you should not force and make a nation change their ways just for being authoritarian.
@9CXF6S82yrs2Y
The EU should sanction for inhumane actions under the government, but not the government itself
@8QBQW264yrs4Y
No, if they are democratically elected
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.