Try the political quiz
+

Reply

 @BDZW99Sagreed…5 days5D

https://www.nber.org/papers/w24312
https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/pol.20200143
Google Stockton SEED and GiveDirectly
And more and more. A dozen or so attempts have been made and each was a resounding success. It typically shows a small improvement in growth and a very big improvement in health, poverty reduction, wellbeing and economic security.

 @BCPXRD7agreed…2mos2MO

It's extremely simple which means it won't cost the government a fortune paid out to some expensive consultancy agency to implement. If it's enough to live on you should have no more homeless and hungry people which will be nicer for everyone even the rich like me who will be paying for this.

 @BBMW262agreed…4mos4MO

Universal basic income would help to ensure that no one is living in poverty. It would also reduce the risk of the current welfare system being exploited.

 @BB29QDVfrom Pennsylvania  agreed…4mos4MO

One can see a list of studies with supporting links here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_basic_income_pilots

This one contextualizes the work disincentive that exists in practice, demonstrating that society is not significantly harmed by that which does exist; it may be paywalled though (it was free to read years ago): https://philpapers.org/rec/PASWTT

For moral arguments:

This book makes a strong moral argument for "freedom as the power to say no" and is free to read from the author: https://widerquist.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/Freedom-as-the-Power-to-Say-No-Independence…  Read more

 @B9WFMMJagreed…5mos5MO

In Kenya 21,000 participants in 295 villages received monthly payments, Poverty fell by 22%, food insecurity dropped by 37%, and school attendance rose by 17%

 @B879HDRagreed…8mos8MO

In Kenya 21,000 participants in 295 villages received monthly payments, Poverty fell by 22%, food insecurity dropped by 37%, and school attendance rose by 17%

 @B866D7Magreed…8mos8MO

https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/international/global-trends/us-news-over-1000-job-cuts-rattle-tech-industry-in-2025-amazon-meta-google-intel-lay-off-thousands-of-employees-check-full-list-of-companies/articleshow/125029264.cms?from=mdr

https://www.nbcnews.com/business/business-news/tens-thousands-layoffs-are-blamed-ai-are-companies-actually-getting-rcna240221

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c07vmllz38jo

While it's not yet fully here as AI is still in it's infancy, the fear of it is real and justified as someone who works in the tech sector. I've personally seen the…  Read more

 @B43Q8D2from Virginia  agreed…1yr1Y

if you don't assist those in extreme poverty, you are no better than the business men of the Victorian ages.

 @9N82957Greenagreed…2yrs2Y

It would reduce mental health issues in terms of the stress and worry about basic living requirements. It would also massively simplify the complex benefits systems and reduce the stigma around people who are legitimately on benefits. If people don't want to work they are always going to find ways around it, so stop trying to get people who don't want to work to work and start focussing on those who do, by providing a better education system based on the technology we have available to us now and what's coming in the near future, more funding for higher education, better apprenticeships and less stress on pupils.

 @9M4NP4Xagreed…2yrs2Y

https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2019/02/the-results-finlands-universal-basic-income-experiment-are-in-is-it-working/

 @9HQS2XTdisagreed…2yrs2Y

Money is a motivation to work - to provide for yourself, your family, your country. UBI removes a considerable portion of this motivation by giving people an income regardless of work done. It supports a laziness. Also, there are plenty of benefits already in existence for those who struggle to make ends meet with their pay-check.

 @B92QC64Plaid Cymru agreed…6mos6MO

A experiment was conducted in California (SEED) where 125 adults were given $500 extra per month on a prepaid for credit card on top of their incomes for 2 years and this money was tracked and categorized.

At the end of the experiments it found that Full time employment rose among the adults (28% --> 40%)

The expenditures on the credit cards were categorized as shown below:
Food: 36.92%

Sales/Merchandise: 22.70% (the report notes some of this likely includes food from big-box/wholesale stores)

Utilities: 11.34%

Auto care: 8.77%

Services: 6.90%

Transportation: 3.45%

Medical: 3.06%

In…  Read more

Self-care/recreation: 2.09%

 @B8YMY6R agreed…6mos6MO

Test cases in Scandinavia, and the new scheme for artists/musicians in Ireland are demonstrating the positive impact UBI can have. Piketty's "Capital in the Twenty-First Century" presents a comprehensive analysis of the impact of capital flow over the past century and makes a compelling case that concentration, rather than distribution, of capital causes more economic harm in terms of growth.

 @9LVKB8Sagreed…2yrs2Y

UBI supports everyone with essential living materials. It will also serve as a means of increasing wages within the job market, the added safety net puts the public and unions in a better position to push for higher pay.

 @rowanbanks from Glasgow City  agreed…2yrs2Y

Everyone having enough money to meet basic living costs benefits everyone is society. It’s also cheaper to administer than the current benefits system.

 @9LV6NHD agreed…2yrs2Y

Wouldn't it be nice to not have to choose between heating or eating? Instead knowing you have some UBI of whatever value to spend on essentials like good fresh nutritious meals?

Demographics

Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion

Loading data...