In May 2024 British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak proposed capping the number of visas the government issues every year. The annual cap, which will progressively be lowered each year to cut migration numbers, will not affect foreign students and seasonal workers. More than 300,000 work visas were given in the year ending March 2024, which is more than double the number granted in 2019, according to official statistics. While the tightened regulations led to a huge decline in the number of health and social care visa applications in May, according to interior ministry figures, care providers have warned that the sector is struggling to fill tens of thousands of vacancies. Labour's shadow home minister Yvette Cooper dismissed the proposed policy as a "meaningless announcement".
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
@9PM87468mos8MO
cap it only for sectors that are over subscribed to ensure sectors aren't left without skilled workers
@9PWBNRS7mos7MO
In areas where the migrants meet the salary requirement but there is no shortage of workers in their profession/with their skills.
@9PZL3SY7mos7MO
No, work visas need to be dealt with differently to family visas until we get the numbers British skilled workers available.
@9ZDBFBK3mos3MO
If they ever find that they’re giving too much out and they’re really giving too much then yes, if not then no.
@9WQKFWK3mos3MO
I believe that the threshold for family and work visas should increased but slow and gradually in accordance to inflation and Market Factors.
@9TS2CGH5mos5MO
Yes, but temporarily and with the view that this is alongside other measures taken to help refugees etc
yes, just in terms of whether or not we have the space, nothing to do with the amount of immigrants, it’s whether we can house and support everyone so that we don’t have homeless people
@9QB7TD67mos7MO
This clearly needs to be flexible, if we need skilled workers who have proven themselves as such then we issue them visas as required.
@9Q7NLSZ7mos7MO
If we need the workers we should let them in but if they bring family they must be able to support them
@9Q72V5Y7mos7MO
Not yet but they need to encourage local population to take these jobs and also return to free degrees to encourage more local people to take up nursing and social care roles
@9QVJ4JV7mos7MO
Yes, but this should be relative to our ability to house and support them, but not for areas in need of skilled workers.
@9QSWQNP7mos7MO
Not work or Student Visas but there should absolutely be a restriction on dependants as the current system is open to widescale abuse
@9QS9QJY7mos7MO
Yes, but ideally there should not be family and work visas granted to anyone beyond the immediate family of children or spouses.
only qualified individuals where there is a requirement for a certain skill should be allowed a work and family visa, like in australia
@9QBL8J27mos7MO
I think they should make sure that family on visas should be consistently working. Offered support if they find themselves out of work
@9NRM82K8mos8MO
Immigration needs to be looked at holistically. Arbitrary caps are not helpful other than to hit metrics.
@9NRGF298mos8MO
Yes, and reform the Immigration policy to ensure those people who will contribute to the country are allowed in, and raise the personal allowance to bring dependents in.
@9NPHN4W8mos8MO
Encourage work and family visas aligned with skills and resourcing needs, e.g. health and care workers
@9QF3TYZ7mos7MO
Possibly if it can fluctuate annually but as that would come at great expense and bureaucracy then no
@9QCWC7V7mos7MO
I think it depends what skills the country requires and if we have the infrastructure to support everyone
@9PXL2XK 7mos7MO
Yes but there should be a cap for different areas of employment so health and social care numbers don’t suffer
No on the work visas,as long as they are working, but if it's wife and kids (21 and under) also a no, but if it's parents and other family then yes
@9PWSYHZ7mos7MO
perhaps for work visas. I do not agree with certain families beinf forced apart because of an arbitrary cap.
@9PVZPJ67mos7MO
If the country can benefit from the work ethic and skill set that can help others then entry should be supported
@9NTM8QF8mos8MO
Yes, but it should be a nominal cap that is capable of flexing as and when required according to the needs of the economy
@9NT5KQ58mos8MO
Yes, but only if they have a job that is useful to the people and country like, building trade, doctor that they get a reduced discount and pay a yearly fee.
@9NSLXLC8mos8MO
Caps are not useful: in times of geopolitical uncertainty, migration is always likely to fluctuate. It’s populist sensationalism and nothing shy of vote grooming to say anything different to that
@9NR7S558mos8MO
It should be constantly monitored not capped. If UK unemployment is low then visas offered should be reduced if UK employment is high then visas can be offered as necessary.
@9NQ9Y448mos8MO
Individual Work visas are important to help the resource crisis but family visas are a burden on the tax payer.
@9PNQ6TC8mos8MO
If necessary, then perhaps for work visas. I do not agree with certain families beinf forced apart because of an arbitrary cap.
@9PGFKCN8mos8MO
Visas should be available according to the need to fill roles not otherwise staffable not supplied to an arbitrary number,
@9PFXXQ28mos8MO
No, work visas are essential to fill vacancies in our public services and allowing family visas ensures the retention of those staff who have come from abroad.
@9P6LYBDConservative8mos8MO
Work Visas should be prioritised for people who want to immigrate to the UK and highly skilled workers like nurses, doctors, teachers etc
@9P26G368mos8MO
Maybe, but this needs to be decided based on factual information, not political opinions or party standings.
@9P252D68mos8MO
We should have a points system so that we allow people with the skills that the country needs are allowed rather than capping a certain number
@9NTVPFF8mos8MO
Visas should be granted for professions that have a shortage like they do in Australia and this should be regularly updated with the countries needs
@9NXQX5K8mos8MO
Only women and children should be allowed on a family visa and men should be screened more before entry
@9NVKTBPConservative8mos8MO
Priority should be given to people qualified in industries that need to use foreign workers due to a lack of skilled uk workers
@9NTWXT5Women's Equality8mos8MO
We need to be humane about the plight of peoples around the world who have no right or safety because of political or gender view etc. we have caused a lot of conflicts around the world so have a moral responsibility to these people
@9NVTVCM8mos8MO
I think we need a fair balance. As long as migrant workers are educated and have legitimate certification of their job they should be allowed to work in the country
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.